Pies & Pints

Pies & Pints anchors the dining scene in downtown Fayetteville, West Virginia, positioning itself as the essential restaurant for outdoor adventurers exploring the New River Gorge National Park and the surrounding Appalachian highlands. The restaurant draws a steady stream of white-water rafters, rock climbers, and national park visitors alongside local regulars, combining creative wood-fired pizzas with a carefully assembled craft beer program focused on West Virginia producers.

The kitchen's signature offering is a rotating lineup of pizzas that move well beyond standard combinations. The pear, prosciutto, and gorgonzola pie has become the restaurant's most recognizable dish, balancing sweet fruit, cured meat, and sharp cheese in a combination that has remained on the menu for years. The green apple and bacon pizza occupies a similar elevated space, pairing sweet-tart fruit with smoky pork. The wood-fired oven delivers crusts with a slight char and a pillowy interior, and the smokiness it imparts carries through every pie. Seasonal additions rotate throughout the year, drawing on locally sourced produce and regional ingredients when available. Salads, appetizers, and shared plates complete the menu for groups with varied appetites.

The dining room has a casual energy that suits its adventure-town setting. Exposed brick walls, wooden tables, and a lively bar area create a welcoming environment that remains comfortable for couples, families, and larger parties. Evenings during the summer season — when the New River Gorge draws peak visitor numbers — fill quickly, and the noise level rises proportionally. The staff navigates busy service with practiced efficiency.

The craft beer selection stands as a genuine highlight. The tap list prioritizes West Virginia breweries, rotating regularly to showcase regional producers from across the state. The depth of the program, combined with the quality of the pizza, has made Pies & Pints a benchmark for dining in the New River Gorge area.

Reservations are accepted by phone and are strongly recommended for Friday and Saturday evenings, particularly during summer. The restaurant at 109 N Court St in Fayetteville sits within walking distance of downtown lodging and a short drive from the New River Gorge National Park visitor center.