Pies & Pints in Fayetteville, West Virginia, is one of the most popular gathering spots in the New River Gorge region, combining a strong craft pizza menu with an impressive selection of more than 30 craft beers on tap. Located at 209 W Maple Ave in downtown Fayetteville, the restaurant-bar hybrid draws a diverse crowd ranging from outdoor adventurers fresh off the river to families, locals, and travelers passing through the southern West Virginia mountains.
The atmosphere is lively but approachable, with a casual dress code that reflects the outdoor lifestyle of the area. Tables fill up quickly on weekends, particularly on Friday and Saturday evenings when the full kitchen and bar operate at capacity. The bar area often sees standing traffic during peak hours as patrons wait for tables, creating an informal social scene centered on craft beer discovery and conversation.
The draft beer selection rotates regularly and emphasizes regional and national craft breweries, giving enthusiasts the opportunity to sample both familiar standbys and harder-to-find selections. West Virginia and Appalachian-regional craft producers are frequently represented on the list. The wine selection, while smaller, provides adequate options for non-beer drinkers, and cocktails are available alongside the extensive tap offering.
No cover charge is levied at the door, and the restaurant operates on a walk-in basis without requiring reservations for smaller groups, though waits for tables are common between 6 PM and 9 PM on Fridays and Saturdays. Larger parties are advised to plan around peak hours or arrive close to opening time.
The location in central Fayetteville makes Pies & Pints an easy stop after visits to New River Gorge National Park or nearby adventure outfitters. The combination of quality food and an extensive beer list has made it a reliable anchor on the Fayetteville dining and nightlife circuit, earning it a loyal local following alongside a strong reputation with visiting adventurers exploring this corner of West Virginia.
Good to know
- Hours
- Sun-Thu 11 AM - 10 PM; Fri-Sat 11 AM - 11 PM
- Signature
- Craft pizza and 30+ craft beers on tap; post-rafting gathering spot
Location
209 W Maple Ave, Fayetteville, WV 25840
38.0527, -81.1045 View on map
Highlights
- More than 30 rotating craft beers on tap from regional and national breweries
- Craft pizza menu that pairs seamlessly with the beer selection
- Central Fayetteville location steps from the New River Gorge adventure corridor
- Relaxed no-cover bar open through evening hours with a mixed local-and-visitor crowd
Tips for visiting
- Arrive before 6 PM on Fridays and Saturdays to avoid the longest table waits
- Ask bar staff for regional West Virginia draft picks to discover local craft producers
- Larger groups of six or more should call ahead to check on seating availability
- The bar area offers informal standing room if the dining section is at capacity
Frequently asked questions
Does Pies & Pints Fayetteville require reservations?
Reservations are not typically required, but Friday and Saturday dinners often involve a wait. Parties of six or more are advised to call ahead to arrange seating.
How many beers are on tap at Pies & Pints Fayetteville?
The tap list typically exceeds 30 craft beers and rotates regularly, with an emphasis on regional West Virginia and Appalachian craft breweries alongside national selections.
Is Pies & Pints family-friendly?
Yes, the restaurant welcomes families and is a common stop for visitors with children exploring New River Gorge National Park. The environment is casual and accommodating for all ages.