Upper West Side 'Sturgeon King' since 1908, serving smoked fish, eggs and bagels.
Barney Greengrass at 541 Amsterdam Avenue on Manhattan's Upper West Side has traded since 1908 and bills itself as the Sturgeon King. It is a Jewish appetizing shop and restaurant, meaning that the emphasis is on smoked and cured fish, cream cheese, eggs and bagels rather than the hot meats of a delicatessen. The signature order is nova and scrambled eggs with onions, and the sturgeon plate, which reflects the shop's nickname, is the other emblematic dish. Bagel and lox, whitefish salad, sable, chopped liver and blintzes fill out the menu, and many items are served with bagels or bialys and traditional accompaniments. The dining room is plain and old-fashioned, with a counter for takeaway fish and a sit-down room that fills quickly with locals, families and visitors, and the mood is casual, friendly and a little brusque. Noise is moderate to loud at weekend brunch. There is no dress code. Beverages are basic and include coffee, tea and soda. The restaurant is a walk-in operation, and long weekend waits are common, so visitors often arrive early or come on a weekday. It typically opens Tuesday to Sunday during the daytime, and current hours should be confirmed. Prices are moderate to upper-moderate because smoked fish is costly, and a sit-down breakfast for two commonly runs a few dozen dollars. The shop also sells fish by the pound for takeaway, which suits travellers who want to prepare a picnic. It is a short walk from Central Park and the American Museum of Natural History, so it works as a breakfast before a day in the Upper West Side within New York City.
| Price | $$ |
|---|---|
| Hours | Typically Tue-Sun daytime; confirm hours |
| Reservations | Walk-in; long weekend waits |
| Address | 541 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024 |
Signature dishes
- Nova and scrambled eggs with onions
- Sturgeon plate
- Bagel and lox
Good to know
- Known for
- Jewish appetizing; known for nova and scrambled eggs with onions
Location
541 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024
40.7873, -73.9767 View on map
Highlights
- Nova and scrambled eggs with onions as the signature
- Sturgeon plate from the self-described Sturgeon King
- Serving the Upper West Side since 1908
- Smoked fish sold by the pound for takeaway
Tips for visiting
- Visit on a weekday to avoid long weekend waits
- Confirm hours before going, as it typically opens Tuesday to Sunday
- Order the nova and scrambled eggs for the classic experience
- Buy smoked fish by the pound at the counter for a picnic in Central Park
- Pair with a visit to the nearby American Museum of Natural History
When to visit
Weekday mornings avoid the long weekend brunch waits.
Accessibility
Access has not been confirmed here. Visitors using wheelchairs should call ahead to check seating and entry, as the dining room is small and can be crowded.
Visit, book or contact
Frequently asked questions
What is Barney Greengrass known for?
It is known for smoked fish, especially nova and scrambled eggs with onions and the sturgeon plate.
Does it take reservations?
It is walk-in, and waits can be long at weekends.
What is an appetizing shop?
A Jewish appetizing shop focuses on smoked and cured fish, cream cheeses and bagels rather than hot deli meats.