Open Travel Guide
  1. Home
  2. Destinations
  3. United States
  4. Massachusetts
  5. Restaurants
  6. Island Creek Oyster Bar

Restaurants · Massachusetts, Massachusetts

Island Creek Oyster Bar

  • CuisineSeafood
  • CategoryCasual Dining
  • Price$$$

Island Creek Oyster Bar at 500 Commonwealth Avenue in Boston's Kenmore Square is the restaurant arm of Island Creek Oyster Farm in Duxbury, Massachusetts — one of the most celebrated shellfish operations on the East Coast — and has served as one of Boston's most important seafood destinations since opening in 2010.

The restaurant arm of Duxbury's celebrated Island Creek Oyster farm, offering the freshest possible oysters from their own beds alongside a full seafood menu. The lobster stew and clam chowder are award-winning.

Island Creek Oyster Bar at 500 Commonwealth Avenue in Boston's Kenmore Square is the restaurant arm of Island Creek Oyster Farm in Duxbury, Massachusetts — one of the most celebrated shellfish operations on the East Coast — and has served as one of Boston's most important seafood destinations since opening in 2010. The farm-to-table connection here is literal and immediate: the Island Creek oysters on the half shell, grown in the cold, clean waters of Duxbury Bay, arrive at the restaurant at their peak condition because the distance between farm and table is measured in tens of miles rather than hundreds. The oyster program is the restaurant's core identity, with the house Island Creek variety supplemented by rotating selections from other New England and Canadian growing regions. The lobster stew — a buttery, cream-enriched preparation with chunks of claw and tail meat — is considered one of Boston's finest and most imitated preparations. The smoked bluefish pâté, a New England product rarely treated with this level of care, is an exemplary appetizer. The dining room is handsome and energetic, with an open kitchen, long communal tables, and a bar program that features beers and wines specifically selected to complement cold-water shellfish. The Kenmore Square location makes it a natural pre-Fenway stop, and the dinner service after Red Sox games is among the most vibrant in the neighborhood.

Good to know

Hours
Mon-Thu 4pm-10pm, Fri 4pm-11pm, Sat 11:30am-11pm, Sun 11:30am-10pm
Reservations
Highly recommended

Location

500 Commonwealth Ave, Boston, MA 02215

Highlights

  • Island Creek oysters sourced directly from the Duxbury, Massachusetts farm — the freshest possible from farm to table
  • Celebrated lobster stew — cream-enriched with whole claw and tail meat — one of Boston's most imitated preparations
  • Smoked bluefish pâté showcasing a native New England fish rarely treated with this level of culinary attention
  • Curated beer and wine program specifically selected to pair with cold-water shellfish
  • Kenmore Square location with pre-Fenway Park dinner service as a natural fit

Tips for visiting

  • Order the Island Creek house oysters alongside at least one other variety to understand what makes the Duxbury terroir distinctive
  • The lobster stew is a full-meal portion despite appearing on the menu as a starter — factor this into ordering strategy
  • Pre-Fenway dinner reservations on game days fill weeks in advance; non-game weekday evenings are significantly easier to book
  • The bar seating accommodates walk-ins and provides access to the full menu when dining room tables are reserved
  • The smoked bluefish pâté is an underrated order that demonstrates the kitchen's commitment to regional New England products

Accessibility

Island Creek Oyster Bar has a street-level entrance on Commonwealth Avenue in Kenmore Square. The interior is open and accommodates wheelchairs throughout the dining room and at the bar counter. Accessible restrooms are available. The restaurant is ADA-compliant.

Frequently asked questions

What is Island Creek Oyster Farm?

Island Creek Oyster Farm is one of the most recognized shellfish operations in the United States, founded by Skip Bennett in Duxbury, Massachusetts. The farm grows oysters in Duxbury Bay and supplies restaurants across the country; the Boston restaurant is the farm's flagship dining showcase.

How fresh are the oysters at Island Creek Oyster Bar?

Oysters sourced from the Island Creek farm in Duxbury typically arrive at the restaurant within 24–48 hours of harvest, having traveled less than 40 miles from bay to table.

Is Island Creek Oyster Bar close to Fenway Park?

Yes. The restaurant is at 500 Commonwealth Avenue in Kenmore Square, a 5-minute walk from Fenway Park. It is one of the most popular pre-game dining destinations for Red Sox fans.

Does Island Creek Oyster Bar serve non-seafood dishes?

The menu is predominantly seafood, but non-seafood options including salads and vegetable dishes are typically available. The restaurant is primarily suited to guests who enjoy shellfish and cold-water seafood.