Highroller Lobster Co. on Exchange Street in Portland, Maine's Old Port, brings a playful contemporary approach to the lobster roll tradition, presenting a short menu of creative variations that update the classic Maine preparation with bolder flavors and premium ingredients. Founded by veterans of Portland's restaurant industry, Highroller operates in a compact counter-service format that keeps the focus on the food and maintains accessible price points relative to the quality of lobster used. The classic Maine cold lobster roll — chilled whole-claw and knuckle meat with a light mayo — is executed with the restraint the dish demands. The spicy lobster roll with sriracha aioli and pickled cucumber has become the signature variation, offering a counterpoint to tradition without abandoning the primacy of fresh Maine lobster. A lobster grilled cheese — warm chunks of lobster meat melted into sourdough with sharp cheddar — reads as an indulgent fusion preparation and has developed a devoted following among Portland visitors who have already worked their way through the traditional roll options. Lobster bisque, available by the cup or bowl, rounds out the focused menu. Exchange Street's central location in the Old Port makes Highroller a natural stop in any Portland food itinerary, and the counter-service format allows a fast, satisfying meal without a reservation.
Signature dishes
- Classic Maine cold lobster roll ($28)
- Spicy lobster roll with sriracha aioli ($30)
- Lobster grilled cheese ($26)
- Lobster bisque ($12)
Good to know
- Known for
- Creative lobster rolls and lobster grilled cheese
- Hours
- Daily 11:00–21:00
- Reservations
- No reservations needed
Location
104 Exchange Street, Portland, ME 04101
43.6570, -70.2561 View on map
Highlights
- Signature spicy lobster roll with sriracha aioli and pickled cucumber — a creative update on the Maine classic
- Lobster grilled cheese on sourdough with sharp cheddar as the standout fusion option
- Classic Maine cold lobster roll executed with restraint using high-quality whole-claw meat
- Counter-service format on Exchange Street in the heart of Portland's Old Port
- No reservation required — a fast, accessible lobster lunch or dinner in central Portland
Tips for visiting
- Order both the classic cold roll and the spicy version on a first visit to understand the full range
- The lobster grilled cheese is best eaten immediately while the cheese is still melted
- No reservations; midday on weekdays is the most relaxed time to visit
- The bisque by the cup is a good-value starter before the main roll
- Exchange Street is central to the Old Port — Highroller fits well into a walking food tour of Portland
Accessibility
Highroller Lobster Co. is at street level on Exchange Street with step-free counter access; the interior seating area is compact. Wheelchair users can reach the counter; limited indoor seating may present challenges for larger mobility equipment.
Visit, book or contact
Frequently asked questions
What is the most popular dish at Highroller Lobster Co.?
The spicy lobster roll with sriracha aioli is the most ordered variation, followed closely by the classic Maine cold roll. The lobster grilled cheese has a strong following among repeat visitors.
Does Highroller take reservations?
No; Highroller Lobster Co. is walk-in counter service only. No reservations are required or accepted.
How does Highroller's lobster roll compare to a traditional Maine-style roll?
The classic cold roll follows the Maine tradition closely. The spicy and grilled-cheese variations depart from tradition, using the same quality lobster with contemporary flavor profiles.
What are the opening hours?
Highroller Lobster Co. is generally open daily from 11:00 to 21:00; hours may vary slightly by season.
Is there seating at Highroller?
The restaurant has limited indoor seating; Exchange Street offers outdoor space in warmer months. Counter service is the dominant format.